Yes, mostly in the sense that it doesn’t do much for succulents. In pots and terrariums, activated charcoal is usually harmless, but it has little proven benefit. Its main downsides are that it doesn’t fix drainage or prevent rot, its capacity runs out, it can absorb some nutrients, and it costs more than grit. Taking charcoal by mouth is a different matter, with real risks, and those are covered at the end of this article.
The main downsides in succulent containers
- It doesn’t create drainage or prevent root rot.
- It doesn’t kill bacteria or fungi.
- It may absorb some fertilizer components. How much is uncertain.
- Its capacity is limited. Once its pores fill, it stops working, and the timescale isn’t well documented.
- Dry charcoal is dusty and needs rinsing.
- It costs more per volume than grit or pumice.
- Not all charcoal is suitable. Barbecue briquettes, wood ash and biochar aren’t substitutes.
It can’t fix drainage or prevent rot
This is the most common misunderstanding. Charcoal’s pores hold onto organic compounds and some odors. They don’t move water out of a container. In a pot without drainage holes, a charcoal layer still leaves water sitting at the bottom, and the roots still rot.
Rot comes from overwatering and poor drainage. The fixes are a pot with drainage holes, a gritty mix, and watering only when the soil is dry.
The benefit is limited, and the capacity runs out
Activated charcoal adsorbs some organic compounds and odors, which is why it’s sometimes added to terrariums. In open succulent pots, the benefit is small and not well proven. It doesn’t make the soil healthier or replace grit.
Adsorption is also finite. Once its pores are filled, the charcoal stops working. How long that takes in a pot isn’t well documented, so if you use it, plan to refresh the layer when you refresh the soil.
Possible effect on fertilizer
Charcoal may adsorb some components of fertilizer, although the size of that effect is uncertain. If you use charcoal, feed lightly. A low-nitrogen fertilizer at half to quarter strength, about once a month in the growing season, is a safe starting point.
Dust, cost and the wrong kind of charcoal
Dry charcoal is dusty. Rinse it before use, and wear a mask when you pour large amounts. Horticultural or aquarium granules are the usual choice, since fine powder is harder to keep in place.
Avoid barbecue briquettes, which contain binders and additives. Wood ash isn’t a substitute either. Biochar is a different product, and fresh biochar can be alkaline, so don’t assume it behaves like activated charcoal.
When it’s worth using
In an open terrarium, a thin layer of 0.5 to 1 cm (¼ to ½ in) can be a modest extra, as explained in our succulent terrarium guide. In a pot, grit and drainage holes do most of the work, and charcoal isn’t required for succulents.
Health warning: don’t swallow charcoal
Garden-grade charcoal isn’t for eating. Medical charcoal is a different use, and some of its risks are serious.
- Doctors use activated charcoal in health care settings, mostly to treat certain poisonings and overdoses. Don’t try to treat a poisoning yourself with it.
- It can bind to medicines and reduce how well they’re absorbed. Ask a doctor or pharmacist before taking it with any prescription or supplement, including about timing.
- It can cause constipation and black stools. Serious bowel problems are rare but possible.
- Don’t give it to anyone who is drowsy or confused, because it can be inhaled into the lungs.
- Evidence for the other claims, including gas, bloating, detox, hangovers and teeth whitening, is weak or mixed.
If someone may have swallowed a poison, call your local poison control center right away. In the US, the number is 1-800-222-1222. If the person is unresponsive, having trouble breathing or having a seizure, call emergency services immediately.